Carmel fire exclusive: Thomas Sullivan Jr. accidentally sparked fire that killed his family

By Shawn Cohen and Terence Corcoran

CARMEL— A lit cigarette flicked by Thomas Sullivan Jr. accidentally sparked the fire that killed his parents and his two sisters, a source close to the investigation told The Journal News exclusively.

Carmel police said the fire was not intentionally set. They are expected to announce the cause of the May 1 fire at a 4 p.m. press conference.

Thomas Sullivan Sr., 48, his wife, Donna, 47, and their daughters, Meaghan, 17, and Mairead, 15, died in the fast-moving fire at their 19 Wyndham Lane home. The lone survivor, Thomas Sullivan Jr., 20, told police and relatives that he was roused by his father, who perished when he went back inside the burning building in a valiant effort to save his wife and daughters.

Thomas Sullivan Sr. was a respected captain in the Larchmont Police Department and a beloved member of the Carmel community, where he volunteered in his children’s youth sports leagues. Meaghan was set to graduate later this month with her fellow seniors at Carmel High School, where Mairead was also a student.

Carmel police detectives and Putnam County Sheriff’s investigators worked alongside members of the Putnam County Fire Investigation Team in determining the cause of the fatal blaze.

Read the complete report here.

Westchester judge denies special prosecutor in child rape, murder case

Westchester County Judge Barry Warhit (left) was called up to Putnam County this week to make a ruling on a 15-year-old case in Carmel involving the rape and murder of a 12-year-old Carmel girl.

Warhit, a relatively new judge who has been praised by both prosecutors and defense lawyers in Westchester for his fair judgements and balanced rulings, denied the defense’s request to appoint a special prosecutor, give immunity to a Sing Sing inmate who may testify and have the court interview every potential witness to check for possible coersion in the upcoming retrial of accused killer Anthony DiPippo.

DiPippo and another man, Andrew Krivak, were convicted of killing Josette Wright, a seventh-grader who disappeared in October 1994. Her body was found in the Patterson woods the following year. DiPippo was granted a new trial last year after a state appeals court found that his lawyer had a conflict of interest in the case.